9 Best Online Lobster and Seafood Delivery Services Reviewed (2025)

If you appreciate seafood but do not live near the ocean, there has never been a better time to have fresh lobster and fish delivered to your door. From wild-caught Maine lobster to Alaskan king crab and sushi-grade salmon, the internet has made it possible to have top seafood delivered to your door for the best seafood experience imaginable, without leaving home.

These are the best seafood delivery services in 2025, reviewed for freshness, taste, and reliability.

*This post may contain affiliate links and I’ll earn a commission if you shop through them. You can read my full disclosure here.

1. Maine Lobster Now

A live lobster with rubber bands on its claws sitting on a white background, showing its deep brown and orange shell.

Best for: Authentic wild-caught Maine lobster and responsibly sourced seafood

Maine Lobster Now was a small family business in central Maine that has since grown to become a national organization that provides direct connections between consumers and local lobstermen or fishermen in Alaska. Having developed a national reputation for quality and traceable seafood with fresh seafood delivered to consumer doorsteps anywhere in the US, lobster is available at Maine Lobster Now in nearly any fashion desired: from live lobsters, fresh lobster tails, pre-prepared lobster roll sandwiches, to wild-caught lobster meat. All deliveries are by overnight service and packaged for ultimate freshness. Also available are Alaskan crab, salmon, scallops, and all other types of delicious seafood. Maine Lobster Now also has interests in sustainability and transparency of the project and has grown to be the most trusted name in fresh lobster shipped from Maine. Whether it be for a celebration or a desire for a taste of the Atlantic coast at home, this is the real McCoy.

2. Citarella

Best for: Fine dining quality seafood and chef-curated selections

Citarella is a gourmet seafood market from New York that specializes in hand-selected fish and shellfish. Every order is selected by expert fishmongers and carefully packed to retain flavor and texture. Their lobster, oysters, and fillets are of restaurant quality, great for special occasions or fine dinner parties. While the prices are higher than those of other vendors, the freshness and quality match those of a luxury restaurant.

3. Luke’s Lobster Online Market

Best for: Sustainably sourced seafood with traceable origins

Luke’s lobster started as a small shack on the Maine waterfront and has grown into a well-loved national brand. Their online market offers lobster rolls, crab claws, scallops, and shrimp, all caught using sustainable practices.

A bright red cooked lobster on brown paper with melted butter, lemon wedge, and beer on a rustic wooden table.

4. The Lobster Guy

Best for: Traditional live Maine lobster lovers

The Lobster Guy is a small business run by Captain Tim Handrigan, but it has a huge reputation. They ship live Maine lobster, fresh-picked meat, and other New England favorites such as bisque and stuffed clams. They have developed a loyal following that appreciates the personal service and a consistent product. If you prefer a simple, straightforward way to enjoy the pure flavor of lobster, this is a good choice.

5. Fulton Fish Market

Best for: Wide seafood variety and restaurant-quality options

Fulton Fish Market was once a legendary wholesale market in New York City and now delivers directly to consumers across the country. It offers more than one hundred seafood products, from lobster and scallops to halibut and tuna.

This is an ideal option if you enjoy variety. You can build your own seafood order, try new species, or restock favorites for weekly cooking. Every product is selected by expert fishmongers who understand freshness and handling at the highest level.

A halved lobster served on a plate, garnished with chopped herbs, ready to enjoy in a fine dining setting.

6. Cousins Maine Lobster

Best for: Ready-to-eat lobster rolls and comfort meals

Popularized by its appearance on Shark Tank, Cousins Maine Lobster has grown from a single food truck into a national seafood brand. They sell lobster roll kits on their online store that come complete with sweet claw and knuckle meat, split top buns, and seasoning packets to be able to make the lobster rolls at home. The lobster comes from Maine and is sustainably harvested, flash frozen to lock in the freshness, and shipped throughout the nation in less than two days. This is one of the easiest ways to enjoy the Maine experience without having to actually go through the cooking process.

7. LobsterAnywhere

Best for: Classic live lobster dinners & gourmet gift baskets

A success story of lobster supply for over three decades, LobsterAnywhere has a strong cachet with seafood lovers for its reliable delivery next–day, good assortments. You may choose lobster size, order tails or meat, and may buy a complete lobster dinner, which includes chowder and dessert. Each shipment goes out fresh, packed with care and following the most straightforward directions for first-time buyers. It's good, in the old way, and the customers are of the type to come back, because they are assured of both quality and service.

8. Cameron’s Seafood

Best for: Maryland crab lovers who also enjoy lobster

Cameron’s seafood is best known for its Maryland blue crab and crab cakes, but its online menu also includes live Maine lobster, shrimp, and snow crab. Cameron’s has been around since 1985 and is a trustworthy name in East Coast seafood. It is a great option if you want seafood blends in one order. Many customers build a crab and lobster dinner for a rich and varied seafood experience.

What to Consider When Ordering Seafood Online

A grilled seafood platter with lobster, mussels, and scallops paired with white wine on a beachside table.

Freshness & Handling

Look for companies that carry fresh, next-day delivery and insulated boxes with either dry ice or gel packs. The less time between catching the seafood and its arrival, the better the quality and texture.

Sustainability & Transparency

Ethical sourcing has never been more important. Look for companies that tell consumers about who they use for fishermen, where they catch their seafood, and any sustainability programs they are involved with.

Variety of products

If you are doing something special, such as a dinner party, check to see that the brand you are looking at sells what you want to use. Some specialize in lobster only, while others sell crab, shrimp, or fish. The greater the difference in companies, the better you will be able to create complete seafood meals.

Customer Experience

Companies that have a good reputation also back their products, their clear policies, and good service. Look at products and services. Look at their product reviews and find out about their returns or policy on returns or replacements if products arrive dead or if a delivery is late.

Extras

Items such as recipes, spices, and preparation and cooking tips will add to the experience of the seafood, especially for those cooking lobster for the first time at home.

Conclusion

The way we enjoy lobster and fresh fish has changed because of online seafood delivery. Whether it’s for a quiet dinner, entertaining guests, or sending a thoughtful gift, these trusted services are convenient and reliable. Maine Lobster Now is an excellent service. With roots in the local fishing trade, an emphasis on sustainability, and the ability to reach customers coast to coast, it is the best choice for those wanting a taste of Maine at home.